Skip to content
Tales Across
Tales Across Rivals · standalone story

The Application

The committee cannot decide: the two best applications are word for word the same. Yet the two authors have not spoken to each other in three years.

A desk with papers in office light

Three of us applied for the grant, and two of us had not spoken to each other in three years.

Those two were Vera and me.

I do not know exactly what happened three years ago. That is the worst kind of anger: you remember the tone, but not the sentence. I know that at a meeting I said the plan would not work, and she said I only said that because I had not come up with it. She may have been right.

Since then we meet in the corridor every month, and every month we greet each other like two strangers who happen to be standing in the same lift.

Three of us applied: me, Vera, and a man from the other group whom nobody knew.

The application had two parts: a written plan and a ten-minute presentation. The plan had to be submitted at the beginning of November.

At the end of November it turned out that the committee could not decide, because the two best plans were the same.

Hers and mine.

Not similar. The same. The same structure, the same method, the same three case studies, in the same order.

I did not understand. Then I remembered an evening three years earlier, when we worked together until dawn, and at the end I said never again.

The chair of the committee asked us to work something out, because otherwise they could not decide. She did not say with whom. She did not need to.

I went to Vera.

“I didn’t copy it,” she said, before I could ask anything.

“I didn’t say you did.”

“You thought it.”

“Yes. But that’s not why I came.”

We sat down. Her office was the same as three years before: the same mess, the same two cups, the same calendar on the wall, only with a different year.

“Do you remember that evening?” I asked.

“Yes.”

“That’s when we came up with the whole thing. You the structure, me the method. Then we quarrelled, and we both acted as if we had come up with it alone.”

Vera looked at the desk for a long time.

“I know,” she said. “It’s the stupidest thing I’ve ever done.”

“No. The stupidest thing was not speaking to you for three years.”

We did not make it up that day. That sort of thing does not take one conversation. But something shifted.

Two weeks later we submitted a joint plan. Not mine, and not hers: a third one, which we wrote together, and which was better than either. The chair of the committee said this was against the rules.

“Then change the rules,” said Vera.

We won. Not the grant — two people could not have that — but another funding award, which we received together.

On the morning of our first day working together she asked:

“Why didn’t you speak three years ago?”

“Because I thought that if you didn’t speak, then I didn’t have to either.”

“And why did you speak now?”

“Because I realised the question isn’t who is right. It’s how long I want to keep nodding at you in the lift.”

Vera laughed. It was her first real laugh in three years, and that was when I realised how much I had missed it.

We did not become a couple. Not then, at least. Two years later we did, but that is another story.

What happened then was something else, and perhaps more important: a person I had thought of as a rival turned out to be my best colleague. And the rivalry was never about beating her.

It was about the fact that alone, it does not work.

Tags: romance · rivals · competition · work · stubbornness

If you liked this, read these next

Tales Across Rivals

The Two Cafés

I open a café at one end of the street in March; in April another opens at the other end. The two owners start leaving messages on their boards.

Reading time: 5 min
Tales Across Rivals

The Chess Game

For fifteen years the same man has sat opposite me at the chessboard every Thursday. Last week I won for the first time, and he did not want to write it down.

Reading time: 5 min
Tales Across Rivals

The Exhibition

The jury cannot decide: I photograph the city at dawn, she photographs it at night. The curator suggests the two of us make one exhibition.

Reading time: 5 min
Tales Across Rivals

The Vote

Twelve sixty-year-old trees stand in the square in front of the building, and twenty-eight cars belong to the flats. The residents' vote ends fourteen to fourteen.

Reading time: 5 min
Tales Across Rivals

The Tower Captain

Arthur Pennock rang the bells at St Brigid's for forty-one years and has just stood down. Nell and I have been rivals since we were fourteen, and there is one captain's seat.

Reading time: 5 min

Don't miss the next story

One email a week: a new story, one short recommendation, and nothing else. Unsubscribe any time.

Subscribe by email

By subscribing you accept the privacy notice.